Form 6-K
Table of Contents

 

 

FORM 6-K

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

Washington, D.C. 20549

 

 

Report of Foreign Issuer

Pursuant to Rule 13a-16 or 15d-16

of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934

For the month of May 2009

Commission File Number: 001-12568

 

 

BBVA French Bank S.A.

(Translation of registrant’s name into English)

 

 

Reconquista 199, 1003

Buenos Aires, Argentina

(Address of principal executive offices)

 

 

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant files or will file annual reports under cover of Form 20-F or Form 40-F:

Form 20-F      X            Form 40-F              

Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(1):

Yes                      No      X    

Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(7):

Yes                      No      X    

Indicate by check mark whether by furnishing the information contained in this Form, the Registrant is also thereby furnishing the information to the Commission pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934:

Yes                      No      X    

If “Yes” is marked, indicate below the file number assigned to the registrant in connection with Rule 12g3-2(b): N/A

 

 

 


Table of Contents

BBVA Banco Francés S.A.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

Item

    
1.    Press release entitled “BBVA Banco Francés reports first quarter earnings for fiscal year 2009”.


Table of Contents

LOGO

Buenos Aires, May 11, 2009 - BBVA Banco Francés (NYSE: BFR.N; BCBA: FRA.BA; LATIBEX: BFR.LA) reports consolidated first quarter earnings for fiscal year 2009

Highlights

 

 

Earnings in the first quarter of 2009 were AR$85.9 million, which represent an improvement of 15.6% compared with earnings in the first quarter of 2008. The earnings per share were AR$0.18 and the return on equity (ROE) reached 16.4% in annual terms.

 

 

The improvement in the recurrent income structure of the Bank is reflected in the net interest margin and in the net fee income, which grew 19.0% and 32.2%, respectively, compared to the first quarter of 2008.

 

 

During the first quarter of 2009, the Argentine financial market showed a slowdown in the pace of growth mainly in the financial intersection with the private sector. In this context, BBVA Banco Francés was not the exception and the Bank’s financings to the private sector remain at the same level as in 2008.

 

 

Regarding asset quality, BBVA Banco Francés continues being the leading bank in the financial system. Prudent risk management is one of the fundamental factors to maintain excellent indicators of risk assumed. As of March 31, 2009 the non-performing ratio reached 1.28% with a coverage level of 159.3%.

 

 

In terms of liabilities, during the first quarter of 2009, recurrent deposits grew 2.6%. Balances in sight accounts showed the greatest growth, increasing their participation in deposits. As of March 31, 2009, these recurrent deposits represented 52.8% of the total.

 

 

Total shareholder’s equity was AR$2,117 million by the end of March 2009 and BBVA Banco Francés had an excess of capital over the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic (BCRA) requirements of AR$938 million. This excess represented 44.3% of Total Stockholders’ Equity, showing an important level of solvency.

 

 

In an Ordinary and Special Shareholders’ Meeting held on March 27, 2009, the shareholders approved by majority the distribution of dividends totaling AR$100 million, of which AR$35 million will be paid in cash and AR$65 million through the issuance of new shares. The approved dividends will be distributed pro-rata to shares held at face value by each shareholder, equivalent to AR$0.21215 by share, “ad referendum” of the BCRA authorization. At the date of the release of this press release, the BCRA had not commented on this issue.

Economic Environment

In the first two months of 2009, economic activity continued to decrease as in the fourth quarter of 2008. The Monthly Estimator of Economic Activity (EMAE) grew 2.4% year over year. Despite this, the industry and development decreased during the period.

A decrease in economic activity and lower agricultural products prices had a negative impact on tax collections and the primary fiscal surplus of the national public sector. Fiscal revenues grew by 15.6% on average year over year during the first quarter. Income tax and export duties were the most affected incomes. The primary fiscal surplus of the national public sector decreased by 49.1% compared with the same period of 2008.

Inflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index (which is used to calculate CER adjustment for some sovereign assets) averaged 6.6% year over year during the first quarter.

 

- 1 -


Table of Contents

While the effects of the international crisis on the markets continued to emerge, some domestic factors also negatively affected the domestic exchange market. The BCRA sold US$1,476 million in the quarter and the exchange rate (BCRA) closed at AR$3.71 per U.S. dollar, an increase of 7.5% with respect to the last quarter of 2008. The international reserve stock remained at US$46,509 million, slightly above its level at the end of 2008.

The Badlar rate at private banks in the month of March closed at an average of 12.21% due to the liquidity stock privilege in the financial system and to the lack of demand for money. Monetary base decreased in the period due to the absence of monetarization via the external sector and due to the integration of reverse repos.

Total deposits of the financial system increased 4.1% on average in the first quarter of 2009. Dollars deposits grew 18.2% due to price effect (greater devaluation), and to quantity. Private sector loans grew only 1.7% in the first quarter, mainly the line of advances in pesos.

The Bank

The international crisis and some local factors resulted in a slowdown in the pace of growth in the core business. Amidst this, BBVA Banco Francés was able to adapt itself to the new market conditions, redefining its strategy with the goal of surpassing this crisis and becoming stronger for it.

In this environment BBVA Banco Francés continues focused on boosting the mixing of business. In terms of assets, the Bank continuous managing liquidity and trying to increase financings in the retail and middle-market segments.

On the other side, in terms of liabilities the targets are the retail funds, which help to improve even more the cost structure. A higher participation of transactional deposits as a percentage of total deposits supports this goal.

BBVA Banco Francés has excellent positioning, which is based on a good balance sheet structure, high levels of liquidity and solvency, a wide network of branches and the necessary expertise to work in an environment more complex and competitive every day.

Presentation of Financial Information

 

 

Foreign currency balances as of March 31, 2009 have been translated into pesos at the reference exchange rate of AR$3.7135 per U.S. dollar, published by the BCRA.

 

 

This press release contains unaudited information that consolidates all of the banking activities of BBVA Banco Francés and its subsidiaries on a line-by-line basis. The Bank’s share interest in the Consolidar Group is shown as Investments in other companies (booked by the equity method) and the corresponding results are included in Income from equity investments.

 

 

It is important to highlight the fact that information contained in this press release may differ from the information published by BBVA Group for Argentina, which is prepared according to Spanish accounting standards for all BBVA Group affiliates.

 

- 2 -


Table of Contents

Financial Information

 

Condensed Income Statement (1)

in thousands of pesos except income per share, income per

ADS and percentages

 

   Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 
   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Net Financial Income

   308,771     (11,249 )   259,535     n.a.     18.97 %

Provision for loan losses

   (32,218 )   35,816     (20,173 )   -189.95 %   59.71 %

Net income from services

   216,882     218,876     164,065     -0.91 %   32.19 %

Administrative expenses

   (376,648 )   (319,283 )   (257,462 )   17.97 %   46.29 %

Operating income

   116,787     (75,840 )   145,965     -253.99 %   -19.99 %

Income (Loss) from equity investments

   13,952     (17,023 )   41,367     -181.96 %   -66.27 %

Income (Loss) from Minority interest

   (4,930 )   (2,467 )   253     99.84 %   n.a.  

Other Income/Expenses

   (37,125 )   114,682     (110,962 )   -132.37 %   -66.54 %

Income tax and Minimum Presumed Tax

   (2,810 )   (3,573 )   (2,315 )   -21.35 %   -21.38 %

Net income for the period

   85,874     15,779     74,308     444.23 %   15.56 %

Net income per share (2)

   0.18     0.03     0.16     444.23 %   15.57 %

Net income per ADS (3)

   0.55     0.10     0.47     444.23 %   15.57 %

 

(1) Exchange rate: 3.7135 Ps. = 1 US$
(2) Assumes 471,361,306 ordinary shares outstanding.
(3) Each ADS represents three ordinary shares.

Net Income totaled AR$85.9 million by the end of the first quarter of 2009, which represented an increase of 15.6% compared to the first quarter of 2008. The advance in the recurrent income structure of the Bank is reflected in the net interest margin and in the net fee income, which grew 19.0% and 32.2%, respectively, compared to the first quarter of 2008.

At March 31, 2009 net financial income reached AR$308.8 million, which included a loss of AR$70 million related to the adjustment in public bonds. Without taking into account that adjustment, net financial income grew 1.3% and 18.5% as compared to the last quarter of 2008 and the first quarter of 2008, respectively.

It is important to highlight that as a consequence of the slowdown in the international markets during the first quarter of 2009, the Bank voluntarily adjusted the public bonds portfolio in order to register this portfolio at a reasonable value in line with the current market conditions.

Provisions for loan losses at March 31, 2009 totaled AR$32.2 million, remaining at similar levels as the previous quarter.

Net income from services showed a slight decrease during the first quarter of 2009, mainly due to seasonality. In annual terms it grew 32.2% as a consequence of higher levels of activity during 2008.

Administrative expenses increased 18.0% in the first quarter of 2009 compared to the last quarter of 2008, and 46.3% compared to the first quarter of 2008 due to an increase in personnel expenses and, to a lesser extent, due to an increase in general expenses.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Return on Average Assets (1)

   1.41 %   0.29 %   1.51 %   390.35 %   -6.44 %

Return on Average Shareholders’ Equity (1)

   16.38 %   2.97 %   14.74 %   452.38 %   11.18 %

Net fee Income as a % of Operating Income

   41.26 %   105.42 %   38.73 %   -60.86 %   6.53 %

Net fee Income as a % of Administrative Expenses

   57.58 %   68.55 %   63.72 %   -16.00 %   -9.64 %

Adm. Expenses as a % of Operating Income (2) (3)

   63.23 %   59.52 %   60.78 %   6.24 %   4.04 %

 

(1) Annualized.
(2) Adm.Expenses / (Net financial income + Net income from services)
(3) Net considering the excess in the adjustment of the value of public portfolio.

 

- 3 -


Table of Contents

Net Financial Income

The improvement in net financial income comes as a result of the steady growth of income coming from the private sector, which is due to growth in the loan portfolio and the low cost of funds on one hand and the decrease in the Badlar rate on the other.

As compared to the first quarter of 2008, the increase in net financial income is due to growth in the private loan portfolio; mainly financings for consumption and commercial loans to small- and middle-sized companies together with an improvement in the client spread.

The increase in Other Net Financial Income is due to an increase in results of financial operations and in the growth of interest of repos with BCRA.

During the firs quarter of 2009, income related to foreign currency exchange, included in foreign exchange difference, totaled AR$40.0 million, which is 12.8% more than those registered in the previous quarter.

 

     Quarter ended    % Change Qtr ended 03/31/09
vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08    12/31/08     03/31/08  

Net financial income

   308,771     (11,249 )   259,535    n.a.     18.97 %

Income from financial intermediation

   128,902     112,689     82,095    14.39 %   57.02 %

CER adjustment

   10,236     32,829     60,471    -68.82 %   -83.07 %

Income from securities and short term investments

   2,605     (316,695 )   20,573    -100.82 %   -87.34 %

Net Income from options

   (2 )   (111 )   —      -98.20 %   100.00 %

Interest on Government guaranteed loans

   4,998     15,210     25,459    -67.14 %   -80.37 %

Foreign exchange difference

   50,938     56,967     31,758    -10.58 %   60.39 %

Others

   111,094     87,862     39,179    26.44 %   183.55 %

Income from Public and Private Securities

Income from public and private securities during the first quarter of 2009 registered a lower adjustment in their value as compared to the previous quarter and appears to be stable.

It is important to mention that the swap of guarantee loans for securities issued by the national government (BONAR 2014) in January 2009 had no impact on the income statements.

With respect to other income from public and private securities, reductions in the results from the portfolio from available for sale and BCRA instruments are mainly due to a smaller volume of holdings of these instruments together with lower yields.

Finally, the decrease in the CER adjustment is due to the lower volume of assets adjustable by the CER index together with the result derived from the application of Communication “A” 4.898 of the BCRA.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended 03/31/09
vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Income from securities and short-term investments

   2,605     (316,695 )   20,573     -100.82 %   -87.34 %

Trading account

   (3,289 )   9,466     13,025     -134.75 %   -125.25 %

Available for sale

   19,548     33,243     26,323     -41.20 %   -25.74 %

Bills and Notes from the Central Bank

   10,071     15,890     42,354     -36.62 %   -76.22 %

Other fixed income securities

   (23,724 )   (375,294 )   (61,129 )   -93.68 %   -61.19 %

CER adjustment

   4,848     14,939     28,642     -67.55 %   -83.08 %

CER adjustment - Trading account

   —       —       —       —       —    

CER adjustment - Investment account

   —       —       —       —       —    

CER adjustment - Other fixed securities

   4,848     14,939     28,642     -67.55 %   -83.08 %

 

- 4 -


Table of Contents

Net Income from Services

Net Income from services showed a slight decrease as compared to the last quarter of 2008, mainly due to seasonality, which caused a decrease in activity during the first quarter of 2009 compared to the last quarter of 2008.

In comparison with the first quarter of 2008, net income from services grew by 32.2%, due to higher business volume with higher fees from the retail segment, mainly those related to current accounts, credit cards and insurance commissions, in addition to those linked to foreign trade operations.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Net income from services

   216,882     218,876     164,065     -0.91 %   32.19 %

Service charge income

   277,865     289,896     205,598     -4.15 %   35.15 %

Service charges on deposits accounts

   108,578     95,699     74,282     13.46 %   46.17 %

Credit Cards and operations

   60,797     76,509     46,094     -20.54 %   31.90 %

Insurance

   27,954     32,233     17,318     -13.27 %   61.42 %

Capital markets and securities activities

   1,533     3,557     3,627     -56.90 %   -57.73 %

Fees related to Foreign trade

   14,758     14,184     12,132     4.04 %   21.65 %

Other fees

   64,245     67,715     52,146     -5.13 %   23.20 %

Services Charge expense

   (60,982 )   (71,020 )   (41,533 )   -14.13 %   46.83 %

Administrative Expenses

During the first quarter of 2009, administrative expenses grew by 18.0% compared to the last quarter of 2008 and by 46.3% compared to the first quarter of 2008.

Growth in administrative expenses is explained by an increase in personnel expenses and in general expenses. Personnel expenses grew as a consequence of the payment of a fixed amount in January and a growth in charges for voluntary retirements occurred during the quarter. Compared with the same quarter a year ago, those expenses grew mainly due to increases in salaries.

General expenses increased due to charges in electricity, communication, taxes, amortization and organization expenses. Growth in taxes is explained by a change in the mode of registration. In the previous years, charges for financial transactions were accounted under Other Expenses. The increase in electricity is due to the increase in tariffs, while growth of the others items are explained by a higher activity level. Those increases were partially offset by lower expenses in advertisement.

By the end of March 31, 2009, the total Bank and subsidiary (except the Consolidar Group) employee base was 4,246 individuals. The branch office network totaled 270 offices, including 239 consumer branch offices, 27 branch offices specialized in the middle-market segment, 14 in-company branches, 4 branch offices for large corporate and institutional clients and 3 points of sale.

 

- 5 -


Table of Contents
     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Administrative expenses

   (376,648 )   (319,283 )   (257,462 )   17.97 %   46.29 %

Personnel expenses

   (236,917 )   (186,297 )   (155,562 )   27.17 %   52.30 %

Electricity and Communications

   (7,357 )   (6,932 )   (6,522 )   6.13 %   12.80 %

Advertising and Promotion

   (12,845 )   (21,754 )   (16,239 )   -40.95 %   -20.90 %

Honoraries

   (7,228 )   (8,550 )   (6,772 )   -15.46 %   6.73 %

Taxes

   (23,026 )   (9,929 )   (7,323 )   131.91 %   214.43 %

Organization and development expenses

   (3,595 )   (3,304 )   (1,850 )   8.81 %   94.32 %

Amortizations

   (10,704 )   (10,100 )   (7,913 )   5.98 %   35.27 %

Other

   (74,976 )   (72,417 )   (55,281 )   3.53 %   35.63 %

Other Income / Expenses

Other income/expenses registered a loss of AR$37.3 million by the end of March 31, 2009, including a loss from legal injunctions paid during the period together with provisions for other contingencies, which was partially offset by recovered credits.

It is important to note that during the first quarter of 2008, BBVA Banco Francés completed the amortization of the asset related with legal injunctions which was of AR$67.7 million. Such amortization was booked in accordance with the BCRA regulation and it does not imply that the Bank waives its right to demand future compensation or recovery of the difference in the exchange rate ordered by the legal injunctions.

Income from Equity Investments

Income from equity investments sets forth net income from related companies that are not consolidated, mainly the Consolidar Group. The stake in the Consolidar Group recorded a gain of AR$11.1 million during the first quarter of 2009.

It represented an improvement compared to the AR$25.6 million loss registered during the last quarter of 2008 as a consequence of the pension system reform.

 

- 6 -


Table of Contents

Balance and Activity

Total Public Sector Exposure

During the first quarter of 2009, the total exposure to the public sector continued losing participation in the Bank assets. As of March 31, 2009, Public Sector National Treasure assets, net of holdings linked to reverse repo transactions, represented 7.2% of the Bank’s total assets. Meanwhile, the total exposure including the portfolio of BCRA bills and notes, reached 11.8% of the Bank’s total assets.

In 2008, the total public sector exposure, net of holdings linked to reverse repo transactions, decreased almost 27.0% mainly by smaller valuations of such assets together with the decrease in the BCRA bills and notes portfolio.

The variations in the provisions for loan loss risk and devaluation in the first quarter of 2009 are due to the transfer of a regulation account that contained guaranteed loan swaps for Bonar 2014, as well as the creation of new provisions.

Total exposure to the public sector includes public debt of the national treasury through public securities, guaranteed loans and trustees, and also, the BCRA bills and notes.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Public Sector - National Government

   1,931,586     2,262,626     2,610,302     -14.63 %   -26.00 %

- Loans to the Federal government & Provinces

   435,189     1,365,552     1,359,054     -68.13 %   -67.98 %

- Total bond portfolio

   2,258,228     1,432,662     1,181,327     57.62 %   91.16 %

Unlisted

   2,078,843     1,004,833     914,461     106.88 %   127.33 %

Available for sale

   83,417     91,669     239,513     -9.00 %   -65.17 %

Other government bonds

   2,946     1,472     27,353     100.16 %   -89.23 %

Reverse repo w/Central Bank

   93,022     334,688     -     -72.21 %   100.00 %

- Trustees

   217,589     217,043     201,342     0.25 %   8.07 %

- Allowances

   (979,419 )   (752,631 )   (131,421 )   30.13 %   645.25 %

Bills and Notes from Central Bank

   3,156,570     2,928,104     1,624,095     7.80 %   94.36 %

- Own portfolio

   1,167,201     1,668,928     1,504,310     -30.06 %   -22.41 %

- Reverse repo w/Central Bank

   1,989,369     1,259,176     119,785     57.99 %   1560.79 %

Total exposure to the Public Sector

   5,088,157     5,190,730     4,234,397     -1.98 %   20.16 %

Total exposure to the Public Sector without repos

   3,005,766     3,596,866     4,114,612     -16.43 %   -26.95 %

Loan Portfolio

The private sector loan portfolio totaled AR$9,609 million, registering a slight decrease in the first quarter of 2009.

During the first quarter of 2009, loans related to export operations grew but decreases in advances and discounted notes in the corporate segment and in consumption financing were also recorded.

In 2008, loan portfolio behavior reflected the important evolution in consumption financing, showing a slowdown in the rate of growth of loan activity. Amidst this BBVA Banco Francés has been able to adapt and has continued focused on the retail segment. Such increase was led by personal loans (AR$342 million), credit cards (AR$325 million) and car loans (AR$195 million). In comparison, in the middle market and corporate segments the discounted notes and other loans, mainly those related to export operations, decreased.

 

- 7 -


Table of Contents

The table below shows the composition of the loan portfolio in quarter balances:

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Private & Financial sector loans

   9,609,422     9,898,442     9,561,341     -2.92 %   0.50 %

Advances

   1,299,454     1,413,526     1,541,802     -8.07 %   -15.72 %

Discounted and purchased notes

   916,839     1,241,508     1,526,031     -26.15 %   -39.92 %

Consumer Mortgages

   927,115     946,804     845,357     -2.08 %   9.67 %

Car secured loans

   505,257     511,374     310,591     -1.20 %   62.68 %

Personal loans

   1,830,322     1,855,767     1,487,916     -1.37 %   23.01 %

Credit cards

   1,183,816     1,239,588     858,656     -4.50 %   37.87 %

Loans to financial sector

   460,431     491,820     561,042     -6.38 %   -17.93 %

Other loans

   2,521,933     2,228,099     2,512,168     13.19 %   0.39 %

Unaccrued interest

   (15,717 )   (24,304 )   (12,284 )   -35.33 %   27.95 %

Adjustment and accrued interest & exchange differences receivable

   188,676     190,749     140,312     -1.09 %   34.47 %

Less: Allowance for loan losses

   (208,704 )   (196,489 )   (210,250 )   6.22 %   -0.74 %

Loans to public sector

   435,189     1,365,552     1,359,054     -68.13 %   -67.98 %

Loans to public sector

   173,083     553,120     625,685     -68.71 %   -72.34 %

Adjustment and accrued interest & exchange differences receivable

   262,106     812,432     733,369     -67.74 %   -64.26 %

Net total loans

   10,044,611     11,263,994     10,920,395     -10.83 %   -8.02 %

Asset Quality

Asset quality continues to set apart BBVA Banco Francés in the local market, with an asset quality ratio (non-performing loans over total loans) of 1.28% and a coverage ratio (provisions over of non-performing loans) of 159.3% as of March 31, 2009.

The increase registered in the asset quality ratio is related to the public sector performing loans decrease due to the swap for public securities in one hand and on the other hand, due to a decrease in private sector loans and a slight delinquency increase.

It is important to highlight that, despite the slight delinquency increase, BBVA Banco Francés has the best quality ratios in the Argentine financial system.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Nonaccrual loans (1)

   131,005     111,026     70,363     17.99 %   86.18 %

Allowance for loan losses

   (208,704 )   (196,489 )   (210,250 )   6.22 %   -0.74 %

Nonaccrual loans/net total loans

   1.28 %   0.97 %   0.63 %   31.89 %   102.12 %

Nonaccrual private loans/net private loans

   1.33 %   1.10 %   0.72 %   21.32 %   85.30 %

Allowance for loan losses/nonaccrual loans

   159.31 %   176.98 %   298.81 %   -9.98 %   -46.68 %

Allowance for loan losses/net total loans

   2.04 %   1.71 %   1.89 %   18.72 %   7.76 %

 

(1) Nonaccrual loans include: all loans to borrowers classified as “Problem”, “Deficient Servicing”, “High Insolvency Risk”, “Difficult Recovery”, “Irrecoverable” and “Irrecoverable for Technical Decision” according to the new Central Bank debtor classification system.

During the first quarter of 2009, allowance for loans losses showed an increase due to the constitution of allowances on the non-performing loans.

 

- 8 -


Table of Contents

The following table shows the evolution of provisions for loan losses, including charges relating to transactions recorded under Other Receivables from financial intermediation.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Balance at the beginning of the quarter

   199,502     248,135     200,629     -19.60 %   -0.56 %

Increase / decrease

   32,218     -35,816     20,173     -189.95 %   59.71 %

Provision increase / decrease - Exchange rate difference

   1,657     2,694     165     -38.49 %   -904.24 %

Decrease

   (21,431 )   (15,511 )   (8,528 )   38.17 %   151.30 %

Balance at the end of the quarter

   211,946     199,502     212,439     6.24 %   -0.23 %

Deposits

As of March 31, 2009, total deposits reached AR$19,380 million, growing 12.3% in relation to the balance registered on December 31, 2008 and 27.8% compared to the balance registered as of March 31, 2008.

However, current account balances in foreign currency as of March 31, 2209 and as of December 31, 2008 include transitory deposits. Without considering these deposits, deposits grew 2.6% in the first quarter and 13.7% in the last year.

At sight deposits, without considering transitory deposits, grew 18.2% in the last twelve months and represented 52.8% of deposits at the close of the first quarter of 2009.

Time deposits increased 3.0% during the first quarter of 2009. This increase is more relevant taking into account the decrease in the Badlar rate during the quarter.

Deposits denominated in pesos decreased 1.9% during the first quarter of the year while they increased 8.2% during the last twelve months.

On the other hand, recurrent deposits denominated in foreign currency grew 23.1% in the first quarter of 2009 and 45.9% during the last twelve months. Although, nominal recurrent deposits in foreign currency, taking off the argentine peso devaluation, grew 14.5% in the first quarter of 2009 and 24.4% in the last twelve months. As of March 31, 2009, recurrent deposits in foreign currency reached AR$3,698 million (equivalent to US$996 million), representing 21.7% of total recurrent deposits of the Bank.

 

     Quarter ended    % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09    12/31/08    03/31/08    12/31/08     03/31/08  

Total deposits

   19,287,904    17,159,319    15,012,593    12.40 %   28.48 %

Current accounts

   6,498,270    4,743,074    3,278,413    37.01 %   98.21 %

Peso denominated

   4,268,206    4,218,204    3,273,369    1.19 %   30.39 %

Foreign currency

   2,230,064    524,870    5,044    324.88 %   n.a.  

Saving accounts

   4,741,144    4,664,305    4,351,764    1.65 %   8.95 %

Peso denominated

   3,123,917    3,338,069    3,276,333    -6.42 %   -4.65 %

Foreign currency

   1,617,227    1,326,236    1,075,431    21.94 %   50.38 %

Time deposits

   7,723,820    7,497,724    7,011,041    3.02 %   10.17 %

Peso denominated

   5,796,240    5,921,364    5,547,552    -2.11 %   4.48 %

CER adjusted time deposits

   8,185    15,326    132,073    -46.59 %   -93.80 %

Foreign currency

   1,919,395    1,561,034    1,331,416    22.96 %   44.16 %

Investment Accounts

   6,683    10,322    17,811    -35.25 %   -62.48 %

Peso denominated

   6,683    10,322    17,811    -35.25 %   -62.48 %

Other

   317,987    243,894    353,564    30.38 %   -10.06 %

Peso denominated

   156,247    127,220    225,275    22.82 %   -30.64 %

Foreign currency

   161,740    116,674    128,289    38.63 %   26.07 %

Rescheduled deposits + CEDROS (*)

   92,557    101,598    155,096    -8.90 %   -40.32 %

Peso denominated

   92,557    101,598    155,096    -8.90 %   -40.32 %

Total deposits + Rescheduled deposits & CEDROS

   19,380,461    17,260,917    15,167,689    12.28 %   27.77 %

 

(*) The payment of Rescheduled Deposits concluded in August 2005, in accordance with its original schedule, except those deposits that have a pending legal injunction.

 

- 9 -


Table of Contents

Other Funding Sources

Other funding sources decreased 44.2% in the first quarter of 2009 and 71.3% in the last year. These variations are mainly caused by the decrease in the balances used at other banks due to the drop in the financings demand by foreign trade operations.

At the end of the first quarter of 2009, 84.9% of the balances showed in the table below were foreign-currency denominated.

 

     Quarter ended    % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09    12/31/08    03/31/08    12/31/08     03/31/08  

Lines from other banks

   217,652    389,832    758,377    -44.17 %   -71.30 %

Senior Bonds

   —      —      —      —       —    

Other banking liabilities

   217,652    389,832    758,377    -44.17 %   -71.30 %

Subordinated Debt

   —      —      —      —       —    

Total other funding sources

   217,652    389,832    758,377    -44.17 %   -71.30 %

Capitalization

As of March 31, 2009, total shareholders’ equity of the bank was AR$2,117 million; whereas the excess of capital over the BCRA requirements was AR$938 million. This excess represents 44.3% of total shareholders’ equity, representing an important solvency level.

The unrealized valuation difference as of March 31, 2009 reached AR$191 million due to the deterioration registered in the value of public bonds labeled as “available for sale”.

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Capital Stock

   536,361     471,361     471,361     13.79 %   13.79 %

Non-capitalized contributions

   175,132     175,132     175,132     0.00 %   0.00 %

Adjustments to stockholders equity

   312,979     312,979     312,979     0.00 %   0.00 %

Subtotal

   1,024,472     959,472     959,472     6.77 %   6.77 %

Reserves on Profits

   658,693     594,391     594,390     10.82 %   10.82 %

Unappropriated retained earnings

   624,852     703,280     456,079     -11.15 %   37.01 %

Unrealized valuation difference

   (190,606 )   (181,119 )   (32,537 )   5.24 %   485.81 %

Total stockholders’ equity

   2,117,411     2,076,024     1,977,404     1.99 %   7.08 %

The variations in the minimum capital required by the BCRA during the last year is mainly explained by higher requirements caused by the increase in the private sector financings and an increase in the alpha coefficient, partially offset by lower requirements due to a decrease in the market risk as a consequence of a lower risk exposure.

 

- 10 -


Table of Contents
     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in thousands of pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

Central Bank Minimum Capital Requirements

   1,467,171     1,467,176     1,449,708     0.00 %   1.20 %

Central Bank Minimum Capital Requirements (a, b)

   1,387,097     1,373,016     1,302,684     1.03 %   6.48 %

Market Risk

   39,465     52,360     91,601     -24.63 %   -56.92 %

Increase in capital requirements related to custody

   40,609     41,800     55,423     -2.85 %   -26.73 %

a) Central Bank Minimum Capital Requirements

   1,387,097     1,373,016     1,302,684     1.03 %   6.48 %

Allocated to Asset at Risk

   958,189     892,463     806,712     7.36 %   18.78 %

Allocated to Immobilized Assets

   89,304     86,167     91,014     3.64 %   -1.88 %

Interest Rate Risk

   167,310     158,065     167,084     5.85 %   0.14 %

Loans to Public Sector and Securities in Investment

   172,294     236,321     237,874     -27.09 %   -27.57 %

Non Compliance of Other Credit Regulations

   —       —       —       —       —    

b) Minimum capital required for Pension Funds (AFJPs) to act as securities custodian and registrar of mortgage notes

   812,177     836,005     1,108,462     -2.85 %   -26.73 %

5% of the securities in custody and book-entry notes

   812,177     836,005     1,108,462     -2.85 %   -26.73 %

Bank Capital Calculated under Central Bank Rules

   2,404,828     2,355,781     2,138,526     2.08 %   12.45 %

Core Capital

   2,257,143     1,946,516     1,935,634     15.96 %   16.61 %

Minority Interest

   316,824     304,884     242,603     3.92 %   30.59 %

Supplemental Capital

   (108,914 )   165,802     55,634     -165.69 %   -295.77 %

Deductions

   (60,225 )   (61,421 )   (95,345 )   -1.95 %   -36.83 %

Excess over Required Capital

   937,657     888,605     688,818     5.52 %   36.13 %

Capital Ratio (Central Bank rules)

   15.41 %   14.76 %   14.30 %   4.36 %   7.78 %

Excess over Required Capital as a % of Shareholders’ Equity

   44.28 %   42.80 %   34.83 %   3.46 %   27.12 %

Additional Information

 

     Quarter ended     % Change Qtr ended
03/31/09 vs. Qtr ended
 

in pesos except percentages

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     03/31/08     12/31/08     03/31/08  

- Exchange rate

   3.7135     3.4537     3.1653     7.52 %   17.32 %

- Quarterly CER adjustment

   1.29 %   1.31 %   2.42 %   -1.64 %   -46.78 %

This press release contains or may contain certain forward-looking statements within the meaning of the United States Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, including, among other things, concerning the prospects of the Argentine economy, Banco Francés’ earnings, business plans, cost-reduction plans, and capitalization plan, and trends affecting BBVA Banco Francés’ financial condition or results of operations. Any forward-looking statements included in this press release are based on current expectations and estimates, but actual results and events may differ materially from anticipated future results and events. Certain factors which could cause the actual results and events to differ materially from the expected results or events include: (1) changes in domestic or international stock market prices, exchange rates or interest rates; (2) macroeconomic, regulatory, political or governmental changes; (3) changes in the markets for BBVA Banco Francés’ products and services; (4) increased competition; (5) changes in technology; or (6) changes in the financial condition, creditworthiness or solvency of the customers, debtors or counterparties of BBVA Banco Francés. Additional factors that could cause the actual results or events to differ materially from the expected results or events are described in the reports filed by BBVA Banco Francés with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), including, but not limited to, BBVA Banco Francés’ annual report on Form 20-F and exhibits thereto. BBVA Banco Francés does not undertake to revise or update any of the information contained herein under any circumstances, including if at any moment following dissemination of such information it is no longer accurate or complete.

 

- 11 -


Table of Contents

Conference call

A conference call to discuss this fourth quarter earnings will be held on Tuesday, May 12th, 2009, at 11:30 AM New York time – 12.30 AM Buenos Aires time. If you are interested in participating, please dial (888) 221 9466 within the U.S. or +1 (913) 312 0669 outside the U.S. at least 5 minutes prior to our conference. Confirmation code: 8487884.

A conference call replay facility will be available from May 12th through May 26th, 2009. In order to listen to this digital replay, please call (888) 203 1112 within the U.S. or +1 (719) 457 0820 outside the U.S. Access Code: 8487884.

Internet

This press release is also available on www.bancofrances.com.ar

CONTACTS

Daniel Sandigliano

Investor Relations

(5411) 4341-5036

daniel.sandigliano@bancofrances.com.ar

Cecilia Acuña

Investor Relations

(5411) 4348-0000 int. 25384

cecilia.acuna@bancofrances.com.ar

 

- 12 -


Table of Contents

BBVA Banco Francés S.A. and subsidiaries (Grupo Consolidar: by the equity method)

 

(in thousands of pesos)

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

ASSETS:

        

Cash and due from banks

   6,440,732     4,239,157     3,388,364     3,596,127  

Government and Private Securities

   4,442,714     3,615,920     2,977,262     2,694,171  

- Trading account (listed securities)

   913     1,461     9,040     20,364  

- Available for sale

   434,366     577,502     978,211     989,689  

- Reverse repo w/Central Bank

   93,022     334,688     —       —    

- Unlisted

   2,078,843     1,004,833     978,345     914,461  

- Listed Private Securities

   7,335     7,796     9,139     20,170  

- Bills and Notes from the Central Bank

   2,807,654     2,442,271     1,350,046     880,908  

Less: Allowances

   (979,419 )   (752,631 )   (347,519 )   (131,421 )

Loans

   10,044,611     11,263,994     11,210,444     10,920,395  

- Loans to the private & financial sector

   9,609,422     9,898,442     9,834,091     9,561,341  

- Advances

   1,299,454     1,413,526     1,471,487     1,541,802  

- Discounted and purchased notes

   916,839     1,241,508     1,424,584     1,526,031  

- Secured with mortgages

   927,115     946,804     953,448     845,357  

- Car secured loans

   505,257     511,374     457,189     310,591  

- Personal loans

   1,830,322     1,855,767     1,786,215     1,487,916  

- Credit cards

   1,183,816     1,239,588     1,010,571     858,656  

- Loans to financial sector

   460,431     491,820     486,909     561,042  

- Other loans

   2,521,933     2,228,099     2,347,432     2,512,168  

Less: Unaccrued interest

   (15,717 )   (24,304 )   (17,077 )   (12,284 )

Plus: Interest & FX differences receivable

   188,676     190,749     159,034     140,312  

Less: Allowance for loan losses

   (208,704 )   (196,489 )   (245,701 )   (210,250 )

- Public Sector loans

   435,189     1,365,552     1,376,353     1,359,054  

Principal

   173,083     553,120     583,740     625,685  

Plus: Interest & FX differences receivable

   262,106     812,432     792,613     733,369  

Other banking receivables

   2,904,596     2,391,717     1,396,491     1,136,726  

- Repurchase agreements

   2,152,752     1,667,345     655,336     120,141  

- Unlisted private securities

   68,624     63,324     58,041     59,389  

- Unlisted Private securities: Trustees

   33,131     34,421     31,326     26,394  

- Other banking receivables

   653,331     629,640     654,222     932,991  

- Less: provisions

   (3,242 )   (3,013 )   (2,434 )   (2,189 )

Investments in other companies

   440,309     428,305     452,879     453,334  

Intangible assets

   48,042     48,075     44,012     28,555  

- Organization and development charges

   48,042     48,075     44,012     28,555  

Other assets

   1,167,927     1,196,426     1,201,050     1,076,042  
                        

TOTAL ASSETS

   25,488,931     23,183,594     20,670,502     19,905,350  
                        
     03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

LIABILITIES:

        

Deposits

   19,380,461     17,260,917     15,674,166     15,167,689  

- Current accounts

   6,498,270     4,743,074     3,454,744     3,278,413  

- Saving accounts

   4,741,144     4,664,305     4,485,715     4,351,764  

- Time deposits

   7,723,820     7,497,724     7,302,332     7,011,041  

- Investment Accounts

   6,683     10,322     18,238     17,811  

- Rescheduled deposits - CEDROS

   92,557     101,598     121,093     155,096  

- Other deposits

   317,987     243,894     292,044     353,564  

Other banking Liabilities

   3,373,442     3,129,562     2,089,996     1,993,905  

Other provisions

   271,528     236,811     344,863     361,146  

- Other contingencies

   271,171     236,454     344,504     360,733  

- Guarantees

   357     357     359     413  

Other liabilities

   306,552     445,672     349,148     391,057  

Minority interest

   39,537     34,608     32,140     14,149  
                        

TOTAL LIABILITIES

   23,371,520     21,107,570     18,490,313     17,927,946  
                        

TOTAL STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY

   2,117,411     2,076,024     2,180,189     1,977,404  
                        

Total liabilities + stockholders’ equity

   25,488,931     23,183,594     20,670,502     19,905,350  
                        

 

- 13 -


Table of Contents

BBVA Banco Francés S.A. and subsidiaries (Grupo Consolidar: by the equity method)

INCOME STATEMENT

 

(in thousands of pesos)

 

   03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

Financial income

   576,047     282,293     492,612     457,432  

- Interest on Cash and Due from Banks

   20     571     3,090     4,914  

- Interest on Loans Granted to the Financial Sector

   27,818     26,492     21,304     14,441  

- Interest on Overdraft

   84,992     89,205     68,514     50,010  

- Interest on Discounted and purchased notes

   44,779     55,879     44,772     38,063  

- Interest on Mortgages

   32,288     31,055     28,826     22,698  

- Interest on Car Secured Loans

   22,443     19,761     15,713     8,488  

- Interest on Credit Card Loans

   44,645     34,570     27,624     21,068  

- Interest on Other Loans

   137,172     139,721     128,702     108,629  

- From Other Banking receivables

   408     4,105     4,691     5,995  

- Interest on Government Guaranteed Loans Decree 1387/01

   4,998     15,210     15,011     25,459  

- Income from Securities and Short Term Investments

   2,605     (316,695 )   (1,935 )   20,573  

- Net Income from options

   (2 )   (111 )   11     —    

- CER

   10,398     33,116     39,070     64,671  

- CVS

   —       —       —       —    

- Foreign exchange difference

   50,938     56,967     40,400     31,768  

- Other

   112,545     92,447     56,819     40,655  

Financial expenses

   (267,276 )   (293,542 )   (237,004 )   (197,897 )

- Interest on Current Account Deposits

   (5,676 )   (8,532 )   (8,009 )   (5,852 )

- Interest on Saving Account Deposits

   (2,441 )   (2,346 )   (2,275 )   (2,130 )

- Interest on Time Deposits

   (218,183 )   (240,262 )   (191,627 )   (151,329 )

- Interest on Other Banking Liabilities

   (6,295 )   (9,006 )   (8,910 )   (12,026 )

- Other interests (includes Central Bank)

   (870 )   (1,707 )   (1,902 )   (1,632 )

- CER

   (162 )   (287 )   (517 )   (4,200 )

- Bank Deposit Guarantee Insurance system mandatory contributions

   (7,338 )   (6,889 )   (6,528 )   (6,632 )

- Foreign exchange difference

   —       —       —       (10 )

- Mandatory contributions and taxes on interest income

   (24,860 )   (19,928 )   (16,629 )   (12,610 )

- Other

   (1,451 )   (4,585 )   (607 )   (1,476 )

Net financial income

   308,771     (11,249 )   255,608     259,535  

Provision for loan losses

   (32,218 )   35,816     (30,108 )   (20,173 )

Income from services, net of other operating expenses

   216,882     218,876     192,471     164,065  

Administrative expenses

   (376,648 )   (319,283 )   (286,323 )   (257,462 )

Income (loss) from equity investments

   13,952     (17,023 )   249     41,367  

Net Other income

   (37,125 )   114,682     (8,062 )   (110,962 )

Income (loss) from minority interest

   (4,930 )   (2,467 )   (2,411 )   253  

Income before tax

   88,684     19,352     121,424     76,623  

Income tax

   (2,810 )   (3,573 )   (3,937 )   (2,315 )
                        

Net income

   85,874     15,779     117,487     74,308  
                        

 

- 14 -


Table of Contents

BBVA Banco Francés S.A. and subsidiaries (Grupo Consolidar consolidated on a line by line basis)

 

           (in thousands of pesos)  
     03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

ASSETS

        

Cash and due from banks

   6,491,378     4,243,080     3,453,787     3,625,974  

Government Securities

   5,998,907     5,233,660     4,533,015     4,482,378  

Loans

   11,433,459     12,507,489     12,619,747     11,966,409  

Other Banking Receivables

   2,960,497     2,442,925     1,443,429     1,186,025  

Assets Subject to Financial Leasing

   343,673     379,120     381,254     335,614  

Investments in other companies

   101,539     96,640     99,574     106,571  

Other assets

   937,207     922,551     959,475     907,629  
                        

TOTAL ASSETS

   28,266,660     25,825,465     23,490,281     22,610,600  
                        
     03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

LIABILITIES

        

Deposits

   19,264,258     17,079,203     15,648,108     15,109,195  

Other banking liabilities

   3,393,066     3,135,153     2,118,476     2,042,381  

Minority interest

   255,787     248,139     261,471     242,604  

Other liabilities

   3,236,138     3,286,946     3,282,037     3,239,016  
                        

TOTAL LIABILITIES

   26,149,249     23,749,441     21,310,092     20,633,196  
                        

TOTAL STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY

   2,117,411     2,076,024     2,180,189     1,977,404  
                        

STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY + LIABILITIES

   28,266,660     25,825,465     23,490,281     22,610,600  
                        
     03/31/09     12/31/08     09/30/08     03/31/08  

NET INCOME

        

Net Financial Income

   447,003     107,969     352,279     358,247  

Provision for loan losses

   (32,218 )   35,816     (30,108 )   (20,173 )

Net Income from Services

   216,303     246,027     240,216     250,923  

Administrative expenses

   (401,236 )   (411,471 )   (350,482 )   (318,297 )

Net Other Income

   (130,860 )   30,744     (79,327 )   (183,634 )
                        

Income Before Tax

   98,992     9,085     132,578     87,066  
                        

Income Tax

   (5,468 )   (6,638 )   (11,559 )   (6,091 )
                        

Net income

   93,524     2,447     121,019     80,975  
                        

Minoritary Interest

   (7,650 )   13,332     (3,532 )   (6,667 )
                        

Net income for Quarter

   85,874     15,779     117,487     74,308  
                        

 

- 15 -


Table of Contents

SIGNATURES

Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorized.

 

    BBVA Banco Francés S.A.
Date: May 11, 2009     By:  

/s/    Martín E. Zarich

    Name:   Martín E. Zarich
    Title:   Chief Financial Officer